Buffalo Nickels (1913 - 1938) (Certified)

Buffalo Nickels (1913 - 1938) (Certified)
Sort By:
Per Page:
1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel PR-66 PCGS
Two distinct types were issued in 1913. This is the Type-I issue with the buffalo standing on a mound instead of a plain (Type-II). Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $4,995.00 $5,203.12
Rare Pick
1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type-II Good-4 PCGS
This is the rarer of the two distinct varieties from 1913. All of the numbers are worn and the buffalo is sharply struck. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $259.99 $270.82
1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type-II VG-10 PCGS
This is the rarer of the two distinct varieties from 1913. All of the numbers are evident but worn and the buffalo is sharply struck. This is the most common grade in most Buffalo Nickel sets! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $279.99 $291.66
1914 Buffalo Nickel MS-64 PCGS
A brilliant and lustrous piece, expected for a coin graded MS-64. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $139.99 $145.82
1915 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
A brilliant and lustrous piece, expected for a coin graded MS-65. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $359.99 $374.99
1917-D Buffalo Nickel AU-50 NGC
This coin is an excellent candidate for a high grade set of Buffalos. Difficult to obtain at this grade level. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $299.99 $312.49
1923-S Buffalo Nickel XF-45 NGC
These coins are almost never encountered at this level of preservation! If you are building a high grade set of circulated Buffalo Nickels, don't let this one pass you by! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $299.99 $312.49
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF-20 NGC
Nice original coin in a Very Fine-20 NGC holder. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $349.99 $364.57
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF-25 NGC
Nice original coin in a Very Fine-25 NGC holder. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $379.99 $395.82
1926-D Buffalo Nickel MS-64 NGC
Tougher to find in higher grades. This is yet another example of a branch mint coin not having nearly as full a strike as the Philadelphia Mint did. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,345.00 $1,401.04
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF-20 NGC
Nice problem free coin with a full date and overall great eye appeal! Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $289.99 $302.07
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF-25 NGC
Very nice original coin with a strong strike and features! Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $289.99 $302.07
1926-S Buffalo Nickel AU-50  PCGS
Great coin for this grade. This coin would fit well in a high grade set of Buffalo Nickels. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $2,995.00 $3,119.79
Rare Pick
1929-D Buffalo Nickel MS-64 PCGS
A super PQ coin. The luster on this coin is truly amazing. A slightly weak strike does not distract. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $349.99 $364.57
1929-S Buffalo Nickel MS-65 PCGS
A nice example with light perimeter toning. This is the lowest minted nickel between all three Mints. This is yet another example of a branch mint coin not producing nearly the amount the Philadelphia Mint did. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $389.99 $406.24
1930 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 PCGS
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has lustrous surfaces that drip off the coin! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $219.99 $229.16
1934 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has lustrous surfaces that drip off the coin! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $269.99 $281.24
1934-D Buffalo Nickel MS-64 PCGS
Very nice coin for the grade. Big jump in value at the MS-65 grade level! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $219.99 $229.16
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has booming lustrous surfaces! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $359.99 $374.99
1935-S Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC CAC
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has booming lustrous colorful surfaces. Rarely do you see Buffalo Nickels tone, especially this nice. The same toning on a Morgan Dollar would command a steep premium! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $379.99 $395.82
1937 Buffalo Nickel PR-66 NGC
Own a popular piece of American coinage. Very rarely do you see proof Buffalo Nickels. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,395.00 $1,453.12
1937-D Buffalo Nickel MS-66 PCGS
Absolutely beautiful coin with superb luster. If you're building a nice 20th century type set, this stunning example is for you. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $89.99 $93.74
1937-D 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel XF-40 PCGS
James Earle Fraser first designed the Buffalo Nickel in 1913. This issue is treasured due to a minting error that makes the buffalo appear to have only three legs. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $695.00 $723.96
1937-D 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel AU-55 NGC
Popular 3-Legged Variety to complete your collection. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $919.00 $957.29
1938-D Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
This lightly toned example has lustrous surfaces that drip off the coin! Really nice coin for a 20th century type set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $49.99 $52.07
1938-D Buffalo Nickel MS-66 PCGS
This flashy Gem Brilliant Uncirculated Buffalo Nickel is a perfect example for a type set! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $59.99 $62.49
1938-D Buffalo Nickel MS-66 NGC
A gorgeous problem free MS-66 Buffalo Nickel. Graded by NGC. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $59.99 $62.49

Items In Cart


There are no items in the cart.

AURIC