Buffalo Nickels

Buffalo Nickels
Sort By:
Per Page:
1913-D Type-I Buffalo Nickel AU
First year of issue. A strong AU coin with sharp detail and nice color. Just the slightest bit of wear is keeping this from being a Mint State coin. Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $49.99 $52.07
1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type-II Good-4 PCGS
This is the rarer of the two distinct varieties from 1913. All of the numbers are worn and the buffalo is sharply struck. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $229.99 $239.57
1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type-II Good-6 PCGS
This is the rarer of the two distinct varieties from 1913. All of the numbers are worn and the buffalo is sharply struck. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $299.99 $312.49
New
1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type-II AU-58 PCGS
This coin is an excellent candidate for a high grade set of Buffalos. Difficult to obtain at this grade level. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $695.00 $723.96
New
1914 Buffalo Nickel Fine
Great affordable coin for a circulated set of Buffalos! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $39.99 $41.66
1914 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 PCGS
A brilliant and lustrous piece, expected for a coin graded MS-65. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $395.00 $411.46
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU-58 PCGS
Nice original look with a nice full horn on this semi-key date. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $399.99 $416.66
1914-D Buffalo Nickel XF-45 PCGS
Nice original look with a complete full horn on this semi-key date. Has claims to higher grades. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $279.99 $291.66
1915 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
A brilliant and lustrous piece, expected for a coin graded MS-65. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $319.99 $333.32
1915-S Buffalo Nickel AU-50 PCGS
One of the toughest Buffalos to find. This coin is a choice piece that looks severely undergraded by PCGS. Rarely do you find a 1915-S this nice. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $599.00 $623.96
1915-S Buffalo Nickel Fine
Nice coin for an average circulated set of Buffalo Nickels. Evenly worn with great details for the grade. Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $109.99 $114.57
1916-D Buffalo Nickel MS-64 PCGS
This coin is an excellent candidate for a high grade set of Buffalos. Difficult to obtain at this grade level. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $499.99 $520.82
1916-S Buffalo Nickel VF
A nice early Buffalo with a full and legible date with great detail for the grade. A higher end VF indeed. Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $49.99 $52.07
1916-S Buffalo Nickel MS-64 PCGS
This coin is an excellent candidate for a high grade set of Buffalos. Difficult to obtain at this grade level. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $729.00 $759.37
1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel Fine-15 PCGS
A very nice, problem-free Key Date Buffalo Nickel. This is a very tough coin to find in any grade and one of the more desirable overdates in all U.S. coinage. This would make a great addition to any circulated set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $2,445.00 $2,546.87
Rare Pick
1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel Good-4 NGC
A very nice, problem-free Key Date Buffalo Nickel. This is a very tough coin to find in any grade and one of the more desirable overdates in all U.S. coinage. This would make a great addition to any circulated set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $749.00 $780.21
New
1919-D Buffalo Nickel XF-45 PCGS
Nice original look with a complete full horn on this semi-key date. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $259.99 $270.82
1923-S Buffalo Nickel XF-45 NGC
These coins are almost never encountered at this level of preservation! If you are building a high grade set of circulated Buffalo Nickels, don't let this one pass you by! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $279.99 $291.66
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF-20 NGC
Nice original coin in a Very Fine-20 NGC holder. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $399.99 $416.66
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF-25 NGC
Nice original coin in a Very Fine-25 NGC holder. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $379.99 $395.82
1929-S Buffalo Nickel MS-65 PCGS
A nice example with light perimeter toning. This is the lowest minted nickel between all three Mints. This is yet another example of a branch mint coin not producing nearly the amount the Philadelphia Mint did. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $379.99 $395.82
1926-D Buffalo Nickel MS-64 NGC
Tougher to find in higher grades. This is yet another example of a branch mint coin not having nearly as full a strike as the Philadelphia Mint did. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,345.00 $1,401.04
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF-20 NGC
Nice problem free coin with a full date and overall great eye appeal! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $289.99 $302.07
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF-25 NGC
Very nice original coin with a strong strike and features! Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $289.99 $302.07
1928-D Buffalo Nickel MS-65 PCGS
Tough Denver issue in this grade - update your collection with this superior example. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $549.00 $571.87
New
1929 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 PCGS
A super PQ coin. The luster on this coin is truly amazing. A slightly weak strike does not distract. Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $329.00 $342.71
1929-S Buffalo Nickel Choice BU
The Buffalo Nickel design is one of the most well-known designs, and has been replicated on coins and rounds for years. This is a pleasing coin with great color and luster. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $119.99 $124.99
New
1930 Buffalo Nickel XF
A nice look with even color and even wear. A great coin for any circulated set. Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $12.99 $13.53
1930 Buffalo Nickel MS-64 NGC
Flashy surfaces with attractive streaks of tan toning. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $84.99 $88.53
1934 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has lustrous surfaces that drip off the coin! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $259.99 $270.82
1934 Buffalo Nickel MS-63 PCGS
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has lustrous surfaces and is very eye appealing. A very strong "LIBERTY" on the obverse. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $119.99 $124.99
1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS-66 PCGS
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has lustrous gun metal surfaces with some small areas of pleasant color. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $599.00 $623.96
New
1934-D Buffalo Nickel MS-64 PCGS
Very nice coin for the grade. Big jump in value at the MS-65 grade level! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $209.99 $218.74
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has booming lustrous surfaces! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $359.99 $374.99
1935-S Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC CAC
Own a popular piece of American coinage. This coin has booming lustrous colorful surfaces. Rarely do you see Buffalo Nickels tone, especially this nice. The same toning on a Morgan Dollar would command a steep premium! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $379.99 $395.82
1937 Buffalo Nickel PR-66 NGC
Own a popular piece of American coinage. Very rarely do you see proof Buffalo Nickels. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,345.00 $1,401.04
1937 Buffalo Nickel MS-66 NGC (Rainbow Toning)
A nice problem free coin with great eye appeal. Nickels very rarely tone this nicely. Everything you would expect from an MS-66 graded coin. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $249.99 $260.41
1937-D 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel XF-40 PCGS
James Earle Fraser first designed the Buffalo Nickel in 1913. This issue is treasured due to a minting error that makes the buffalo appear to have only three legs. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $695.00 $723.96
1937-D 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel AU-58 NGC
Light high-point wear and even gray surfaces appear on this near-mint key-date. This is the quintessential buffalo nickel and without question the key to the series. This example is perfect to finish a collection of nickels. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,295.00 $1,348.96
1938-D Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
This flashy Gem Brilliant Uncirculated Buffalo Nickel is a perfect example for a type set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $49.99 $52.07

Items In Cart


There are no items in the cart.

AURIC