hp-free-shipping-truck Free Shipping On Orders Over $99

Indian Head Pennies (1859 - 1909) (Certified)

Indian Head Pennies (1859 - 1909) (Certified)
Sort By:
Per Page:
1859 Indian Head Cent AU-50 NGC
This first year of issue coin has great color and eye appeal. This is the first of 6 years in which the cent was made of Copper-Nickel. A great piece for a type set or a great piece for a high grade Indian Head Cent set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $179.99 $187.49
1859 Indian Head Cent AU-53 NGC
This first year of issue coin has great color and eye appeal. This is the first of 6 years in which the cent was made of Copper-Nickel. A great piece for a type set or a great piece for a high grade Indian Head Cent set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $199.99 $208.32
1859 Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS
This first year of issue coin has great color and eye appeal. This is the first of 6 years in which the cent was made of Copper-Nickel. A great piece for a type set or a great piece for a high grade Indian Head Cent set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,079.00 $1,123.96
1860 Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $429.99 $447.91
1860 Indian Head Cent PR-64 PCGS
Nice even color adds to the overall eye appeal of this issue. This coin would fit well in a nice type set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $2,095.00 $2,182.29
1861 Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS
This is the third of 6 years in which the cent was made of Copper-Nickel. A great piece for a type set or a great piece for a Mint State Indian Head set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $645.00 $671.87
1862 Indian Head Cent MS-65 NGC
This coin has great color and eye appeal. This is the fourth of 6 years in which the cent was made of Copper-Nickel. A great piece for a type set or a great piece for a Mint State Indian Head Cent set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $895.00 $932.29
1863 Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS
This coin has great color and eye appeal. This is the third of 6 years in which the cent was made of Copper-Nickel. A great piece for a type set or a great piece for a Mint State Indian Head set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $317.99 $331.24
1863 Indian Head Cent MS-65 PCGS
This coin has great color and eye appeal. This is the third of 6 years in which the cent was made of Copper-Nickel. A great piece for a type set or a great piece for a Mint State Indian Head set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $949.99 $989.57
1864 Indian Head Cent XF-40 NGC (CN)
Struck in Copper-Nickel, this coin has a nice even color on both the obverse and reverse, which adds to the overall eye appeal of this issue. This coin would fit well in a nice type set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $94.99 $98.95
1864 Indian Head Cent Copper-Nickel MS-64 PCGS
This Copper-Nickel 1864 Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-64 by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. These would be designated as Red or Red/Brown if PCGS assigned color designation to copper-nickel coinage. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $595.00 $619.79
1864 Indian Head Cent MS-65 PCGS CAC (CN)
This 1864 Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-65 by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 184 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,445.00 $1,505.21
1864 Indian Head Cent Bronze MS-66 NGC (Red/Brown)
This 1864 Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-66 (Red/Brown) by NGC, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 69 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $845.00 $880.21
1866 Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS CAC (Red/Brown)
This 1866 Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-64 (Red/Brown) by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This highly collectible coin is a great addition to any numismatic collection. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,020.00 $1,062.50
1867 Indian Head Cent XF-40 PCGS
Slightly better date in the series with less than 10 million made. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $169.99 $177.07
1871 Indian Head Cent F-15 PCGS
Nice for the grade! Slightly better date from the early part of the series. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $249.99 $260.41
1872 Indian Head Cent AU-50 NGC (Brown)
This 1872 Indian Head Cent has been certified as AU-50 (Brown) by NGC, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 43 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $649.99 $677.07
1872 Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS (Brown)
This 1872 Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-64 (Brown) by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 54 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,245.00 $1,296.87
1873 Indian Head Cent Open 3 VF-35 NGC
This coin is a choice Very Fine. Great chocolate brown surfaces add to its attractiveness. A nice affordable Indian from the 1870s. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $149.99 $156.24
1873 Indian Head Cent Closed 3 PR-65 PCGS CAC (Red/Brown)
This beautiful low mintage coin would fit well in any set of Indian Head Cents. Coins at this level of preservation are seldom available and this particular coin includes the "Red/Brown" designation as well, with plenty of original red stil.... Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $899.00 $936.46
1875 Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS CAC (Red/Brown)
This coin is a beautiful red/brown with great detail. This coin features fantastic color, with significant remaining red surfaces. Really nice for a type set. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $645.00 $671.87
1877 Indian Head Cent VG-10 PCGS
Certified by PCGS! Great even color! LIBERTY Is Nearly Complete! Read More
Back In Stock
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $675.00 $703.12
1877 Indian Head Cent XF-40 NGC
This beautiful key date coin would fit well in any set of Indian Head Cents. Coins at this level of preservation are seldom available. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,949.00 $2,030.21
1877 Indian Head Cent AU-55 NGC (Brown)
This 1877 Indian Head Cent has been certified as AU-55 (Brown) by NGC, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 78 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $2,795.00 $2,911.46
New
1877 Indian Head Cent MS-65+ PCGS CAC (Red)
This 1877 Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-65+ (Red) by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 3 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $55,245.00 $57,546.87
Rare Pick
1880 Indian Head Cent PR-66 PCGS (Brown)
This 1880 Indian Head Cent has been certified a Proof-66 by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 11 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $2,245.00 $2,338.54
1881 Indian Head Cent PR-66 PCGS (Red/Brown)
This 1881 Indian Head Cent has been certified as PR-66 (Red/Brown) by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 38 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,795.00 $1,869.79
1873 Indian Head Cent Open 3 MS-65 PCGS CAC (Brown)
This beautiful low mintage coin would fit well in any set of Indian Head Cents. Coins at this level of preservation are seldom available and this particular coin has plenty of original red still present, but not enough to call it Red/Brown. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $995.00 $1,036.46
1887 Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS (Red)
This coin has a sharp strike and is full Red. Red Indians are becoming harder and harder to find in the marketplace! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $499.99 $520.82
1888/7 Indian Head Cent AU-55 NGC (Brown)
This 1888/7 Indian Head Cent has been certified as AU-55 (Brown) by NGC, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 19 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $13,995.00 $14,578.12
1889 Indian Head Cent PR-65 PCGS (Red)
This 1889 Indian Head Cent has been certified as PR-65 (Red) by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 16 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,845.00 $1,921.87
1894 Indian Head Cent MS-65 PCGS (Red)
This 1894 Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-65 (Red) by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 101 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,045.00 $1,088.54
1899 Indian Head Cent MS-66 PCGS (Red)
This 1899 Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-66 (Red) by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 112 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,445.00 $1,505.21
1901 Indian Head Cent PR-66 PCGS (Red/Brown)
This 1901 Indian Head Cent has been certified PR-66 Red/Brown by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 50 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,195.00 $1,244.79
1902 Indian Head Cent MS-65 PCGS (Red)
This Red Gem Indian Head Cent is the perfect coin to add to any Mint State set of Indian Head Cents or would fit well in a high grade type set. Full Red surfaces make this coin especially eye appealing! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $579.00 $603.12
1904 Indian Head Cent PR-66 PCGS (Red)
This 1904 Indian Head Cent has been certified as PR-66 (Red) by PCGS, one of the top two coin grading services. This coin has a population of only 8 coins! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $2,945.00 $3,067.71
1905 Indian Head Cent MS-65 PCGS (Red)
This Red Gem Indian Head Cent is the perfect coin to add to any Mint State set of Indian Head Cents or would fit well in a high grade type set. Full Red surfaces make this coin especially eye appealing! Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $545.00 $567.71
1906 Indian Head Cent VG-8 NGC (Error, Struck 10% Off Center)
Really neat Mint Error struck 10 percent off center. Nice condition for a coin minted over 110 years ago. This coin has nice even wear as well as chocolate brown surfaces. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $349.99 $364.57
1908-S Indian Head Cent MS-65 PCGS (Red)
One of only two mintmarked coins in the entire Indian Head Cent Series. This coin has extremely nice eye appeal as it has been graded with the full RED designation. Rarely seen in this high of a grade. Only 59 coins graded higher with thi.... Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $2,395.00 $2,494.79
1908-S Indian Head Cent MS-65 NGC (Red)
This 1908-S Indian Head Cent has been certified as MS-65 (Red) by NGC, one of the top two coin grading services. Read More
Volume Pricing
Quantity Check/Wire CC/PayPal
Any Quantity $1,995.00 $2,078.12

Items In Cart


There are no items in the cart.

AURIC