Cart:

(0)

Buffalo Nickels (1913-1938)

Sort by
Default
Most Popular
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Weight: Ascending
Weight: Descending
Year: Ascending
Year: Descending
Highest Rated
Sale
On Sale (13)
Clearance (8)
Product Type
Coin (547)
Proof Coin (10)
Supplies (3)
Year
Random (9)
1938 (23)
1937 (51)
1936 (24)
1935 (22)
1934 (16)
1931 (10)
1930 (12)
1929 (22)
1928 (14)
1927 (22)
1926 (23)
1925 (19)
1924 (20)
1923 (17)
1921 (14)
1920 (19)
1919 (23)
1918 (24)
1917 (22)
1916 (30)
1915 (28)
1914 (31)
1913 (60)
See More
Grade
Brilliant Uncirculated (28)
Proof - 68 (5)
MS-68 (3)
Proof - 67 (5)
MS-67 (33)
MS-66 (42)
MS-65 (45)
MS-64 (25)
MS-63 (14)
MS-62 (9)
MS-61 (2)
Almost Uncirculated - 58 (5)
Almost Uncirculated - 55 (3)
Almost Uncirculated - 53 (3)
Almost Uncirculated - 50 (3)
Almost Uncirculated (39)
Extra Fine - 45 (5)
Extra Fine - 40 (2)
Extra Fine (56)
Very Fine - 35 (5)
Very Fine - 30 (6)
Very Fine - 25 (2)
Very Fine - 20 (2)
Very Fine (53)
Fine - 15 (3)
Fine - 12 (2)
Fine (42)
Very Good (27)
Good/Very Good (1)
Good or Better (1)
Good - 6 (1)
Good - 4 (1)
Good (53)
Almost Good - 3 (1)
Almost Good (17)
Average Circulated (6)
Cull (1)
Other (6)
None (3)
See More
Attributes
+ (38)
* (STAR) (1)
CAC (7)
Mint Error (2)
Price
Under $25 (148)
$25 to $99 (106)
$100 to $499 (137)
$500 to $999 (43)
$1,000 to $2,500 (50)
Over $2,500 (48)
Min Price
Max Price
Availability
New (1)
In Stock (495)
All Available (495)
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS-65 NGC
$559.00
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
51,424,029 142
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS-67 NGC
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS-67 NGC
$5,229.00
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
51,424,029 10
1917-D Buffalo Nickel VF-25 NGC
1917-D Buffalo Nickel VF-25 NGC
$119.99
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
9,910,800 137
1917-D Buffalo Nickel AU-50 NGC
1917-D Buffalo Nickel AU-50 NGC
$329.99
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
9,910,800 20
1918-D Buffalo Nickel MS-62 NGC
1918-D Buffalo Nickel MS-62 NGC
$859.00
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
8,362,000 84
New
1918-D Buffalo Nickel MS-63 PCGS
1918-D Buffalo Nickel MS-63 PCGS
$1,179.00
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
8,362,000 188
1919 Buffalo Nickel MS-63 PCGS
1919 Buffalo Nickel MS-63 PCGS
$174.99
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
60,868,000 378
1919 Buffalo Nickel MS-64 PCGS
1919 Buffalo Nickel MS-64 PCGS
$299.99
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
60,868,000 856
1919-S Buffalo Nickel VF-20 NGC
1919-S Buffalo Nickel VF-20 NGC
$134.99
Any Quantity
Grade Mintage Population
7,521,000 196

Buffalo Nickels: A Tribute to the American West

The Buffalo Nickel, officially known as the Indian Head Nickel, holds a significant place in American numismatic history. Introduced in 1913, it featured a unique design that showcased a majestic American bison, or buffalo, on the reverse and a Native American chief on the obverse. This iconic coin, designed by James Earle Fraser, aimed to pay homage to the rugged spirit and cultural heritage of the American West.

The Buffalo Nickel was widely celebrated for its artistic beauty and symbolic representation. The intricate details of the buffalo, with its powerful stance and massive frame, captured the essence of the American wilderness. On the obverse, the portrait of a Native American chief, believed to be a composite of Chief Iron Tail of the Lakota Sioux and Chief Two Moons of the Cheyenne, symbolized the Native American contributions to the nation's history.

What is a Buffalo Nickel Worth?: Value and Rarity

The value of a Buffalo Nickel can vary significantly depending on several factors. Common Buffalo Nickels in circulated condition can be obtained for their face value or a slight premium. However, coins in better condition or those with specific characteristics may command higher prices in the collector's market.

Key factors that determine the value of a Buffalo Nickel include its condition, mintmark, and any notable variations or errors. The higher the grade of the coin, indicating its preservation and absence of wear, the more valuable it tends to be. Mintmarked Buffalo Nickels from specific mints, such as the San Francisco mint (identified by the "S" mark), are often sought after by collectors and can fetch higher prices.

Certain rare variations or errors in Buffalo Nickels can significantly increase their value. For instance, the 1916-D Buffalo Nickel with a raised mound on the reverse instead of a flat ground is highly prized. Additionally, the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel, featuring a distinctive legless appearance on the buffalo due to an overpolished die, is a famous and sought-after variety.

Whether you collect Buffalo Nickels or other U.S. coins, explore the value of U.S. Mint coins and discover something new about your collection.

Historic Numismatic Coins: Collecting Buffalo Nickels

Buffalo Nickels have become a favorite among collectors, history enthusiasts, and those captivated by the allure of the American West. Their unique design, rich symbolism, and historical significance make them cherished numismatic treasures.

Collecting Buffalo Nickels offers an opportunity to connect with America's past, preserving a tangible piece of its numismatic heritage. Many collectors seek to assemble complete sets, which consist of the main series and its numerous variations, including different mintmarks and years.

As with any collectible, it is essential to educate oneself about grading standards, authentication techniques, and the market value of Buffalo Nickels before making purchases. Engaging with reputable dealers, attending coin shows, and consulting numismatic references can help collectors make informed decisions and build a rewarding Buffalo Nickel collection.

Other popular U.S. Nickels to collect include the Jefferson Nickels series, which is still in production today. Many of these can be exceptionally affordable to collect, such as the 1946-D Jefferson Nickel coin. This only costs a bit more than its face value, making it an easy entry point into collecting other American Nickels.

Rare Buffalo Nickels for Sale: Discovering Numismatic Gems

For collectors seeking rare and elusive Buffalo Nickels, there are various avenues to explore. Reputable coin dealers and online marketplaces offer an extensive selection of Buffalo Nickels, ranging from common dates to scarce and valuable varieties.

When searching for rare Buffalo Nickels, it is crucial to be aware of their rarity, condition, and authenticity. Rare dates, mintmarks, or errors command higher premiums, especially when combined with well-preserved condition. Collectors should also consider obtaining certified coins graded by reputable third-party grading services, which provide assurance regarding the coin's authenticity and condition.

Rare Buffalo Nickels, such as the aforementioned 1916-D and 1937-D Three-Legged varieties, can be found through specialized numismatic auctions, private sales, and dedicated d coin shows. These unique coins present an exciting opportunity to own a piece of American numismatic history and delve into the captivating world of rare coin collecting.

210,000+ Customer Reviews
4.9 Overall Satisfaction Rating, the Highest Score in the Industry
Check out what other customers are saying.

Items in Cart (0)


There are no items in the cart.

APXIIS01